Coronavirus (COVID-19) Update: We are fully operational and remote, we are available over the phone 8am-5pm Monday-Friday, available over email and able to provide services to our existing and future clients. More FAQs »

Mon-Fri 8AM-5PM
English or Spanish


Who Is Liable in an Emergency Room Malpractice Case?

Hospitals are responsible for malpractice cases involving their employees. In many cases, the doctor, who is not employed, but contracted to administer certain services, is liable for malpractice. In the Emergency Room (ER), most often hospitals are held responsible for the medical malpractice of all ER practitioners.

Most first responders to medical emergencies are protected from lawsuits by special statutes that vary from state to state. However, for doctors, nurses, and other medical personnel working in the emergency room, the standard medical rules apply.

A medical professional acts negligently by failing to provide the quality of care that other reasonably competent medical providers would have ensured under similar circumstances.

In normal circumstances, hospitals are responsible for the malpractice cases involving their employees such as doctors, nurses, and auxiliary personnel.

Why Does Emergency Room Care Differ From Standard Medical Care?

In a non-emergency situation, when doctors serve as contractors, they are held responsible for any malpractice cases they may be engaged in. To ensure this, a patient is always made aware that such doctors are independent of the hospital.

However, this is not easy to communicate in emergency rooms for two reasons:

  • When a patient comes in with an emergency, he or she goes to the emergency room, not to a specific doctor.
  • There is limited time to inform such a patient about the status of the practitioner in attendance.

Also, you need to keep in mind that the medical context of an emergency room greatly differs from that of standard medical practice. The split-second decisions are the most common ways of going forth in a life or death situation. Thus, the mistakes made by medical professionals often need to be fairly severe in order to rise to the level of negligence.

Determining Liability in an Emergency Room Medical Malpractice Case

Generally, all employees who are hired by a hospital are regarded to be acting within the scope of employment. In such cases, hospitals are often held responsible for the medical malpractices of all ER practitioners, including independent doctors. This is because the patient is going to the ER, not a particular doctor specialized in a certain medical branch. There are only very few instances where ER personnel can be held directly liable for an act of negligence.

The burden of proof lies with the patient to prove that the act of negligence, recklessness, or even intentional ill-will of the ER personnel allegedly involved in the malpractice case, would not have been made by a competent doctor under the same circumstances. At The Law Offices of Sean M. Cleary, we are experts in determining responsibility in such cases. Relying on us in your emergency room malpractices case makes it so much easier to determine who is directly responsible.

For questions and free legal advice to help individuals please call us

Disclaimer: Please note that the information provided on this site is not formal legal advice, also the site does not allow you to form an attorney-client relationship.